argument analysis introduction and thesis

Sarah High

Mrs. Thomas

SEGL 102

17 February 2013

How to live the American Dream:

The Debate over Immigration Reform

            For years one specific topic has been brought up to congress over and over again, but yet it continues to be debated over with little progress being made leaving our country feeling there’s no end in sight.  Immigration reform seems to be an issue our Government has a problem laying down a solid law for.  This leaves not only our country but President Obama in frustration.  As American citizens are striving and struggling to make a living for themselves, many have a hard time dealing with so many immigrants residing on US land because they feel it takes away from their living, while others find it to be beneficial for everyone.  President Obama sees every American and immigrants’ point of view on the topic, and has struggled with Congress since his first term with a proposal for immigration reform. 

            Our President first laid out the DREAM Act, having solid evidence for ways he feels will work to boost our economy, and at the same time allow those wanting to live the American dream to do so successfully.  But while the debate continues, illegal immigrants are continuing to have American born children and more immigrants are sneaking into the country, which is making it even more difficult to take control over immigration reform.  With many putting demands on Congress to make quick decisions, some are trying to persuade them in believing immigrants brought in the country are damaging our economy putting us at risk for a downward spiral, while others are presenting solid evidence to prove differently.

            Two people specifically, one of which is a Senator, have written articles stating their reasons why immigration reform will be beneficial to our economy.  Senator Marco Rubio wrote “Ex-Las Vegan Rubio Outlines a GOP Vision for Immigration Reform” which was published for the Las Vegas Review, and David Brooks wrote “The Easy Problem” for The New York Times.  Both of these men agree with a rush needing to be put on the policy to benefit our economy giving evidence throughout to support their arguments; however they disagree with how to legalize those who are here illegally.  While comparing the two articles, David Brooks gives more evidence to prove his stance on the topic, and Marco Rubio uses his political knowledge for his claim.